• Home
  • EV News
  • EV Blogs
  • Podcast
  • Videos
  • Vehicles
    • Sales
    • Electric Cars
    • Tata Electric Cars
    • OLA Electric
    • Power Electric Scooters
    • Economy Scooters
    • Electric Cycles
    • Electric MotorCycles
    • Electric Cargo Vehicles
    • Campus Vehicles
  • Categories
    • Community Charging
    • Buyer's Guides
    • Real Life EV Stories
    • How To Guides
    • EV Test Reports
    • EV Travelogues
    • EV Conversions
    • Events
    • Educate
  • About Us
  • Community
    • Discord
    • Forums
PluginIndia Electric Vehicles

Ather Energy vs Hero Electric - War of words. FAME and Subsidies

20/2/2021

7 Comments

 
By Kamlesh Mallick
With inputs from EV Industry
When it comes to India's FAME 2 scheme for promotion of electric vehicles, there has been a conflicting perceptive between two leading figures in the Indian EV industry. 
On one hand you have Mr Sohinder Gill, CEO of Hero Electric and also director general of Society of Manufacturers of Electric Vehicles (SMEV) and on the other hand you have, Tarun Mehta, CEO of Ather Energy. So let's discuss!
Video: Ather Energy vs Hero Electric - Who is right?

Conflict within our Industry
So consider this statement from Mr Sohinder Gill, CEO of Hero Electric and also director general of Society of Manufacturers of Electric Vehicles (SMEV)

"It's been almost 2 years of the FAME II scheme and only less than 10 percent of its target of selling 10 lakh electric two wheelers has been achieved. Make changes to FAME 2 or reintroduce the FAME I scheme."


Consider this counter statement from Tarun Mehta, CEO of Ather Energy
"What SMEV has said does not look like a considered industry view.  A policy like FAME-II is not just a demand creation policy. It is actually about creating the right product. It is restructuring the entire EV industry to build a new kind of product for the consumer.
In fact I am deeply disappointed by the view published by the organisation. After almost 14 years of selling EVs in the country the time for  importing China-made vehicles is well past its expiry date"

So who is right? Ather’s Tarun Mehta or Sohinder Gill’s Hero Electric?

But first a mini refresher course.
FAME and FAME 2 Schemes
FAME India (Faster Adoption and Manufacturing of Electric Vehicles) scheme was an 800 CR scheme announced back in 2015, which offered incentives to all electric vehicles. Irrespective of the battery chemistry or the fact that entire EV’s were being imported from other countries.

FAME 2 was a more advanced scheme that allocated 10,000 CR, which had emphasis for public transport, EV charging infra, commercial vehicles and two wheelers. Apart from that FAME 2 ensured at-least 50% of components used in an EV had to be localized and Made in India in order to get the subsidy.

So according to us, FAME 2 is a superior scheme, which upped the ante and ensured the Indian EV industry did not get substandard products from China and dump it into Indian market. And we have seen the benefits of such a scheme. Multiple companies like Hero Electric, Ampere, Okinawa which used to import everything had to scramble around and take localization seriously. 
And now most electric 2 wheeler companies, commercial vehicle OEMs, bus companies have localized to more than 60% and many of them are targeting 95 to 100% Made In India products soon. 
​
So FAME 2 has certainly given a direction to the Industry and now companies are preferring to Make in India. Which is fantastic.


Hero Electric : Where is the innovation?
Now back to Mr Sohinder Gill from Hero Electric. He is advocating for changes to the FAME 2 scheme and even wants FAME 1 back. Now why would he want FAME 1 back? You see Hero Electric sold around 50,000 electric scooters in 2019 and more than 90% of these were low speed electric scooters which don't have any subsidy. Essentially he wants subsidies for low speed scooters, so that he can beat his company’s  previous year targets. The question is why does a 15 year old company like Hero Electric need subsidies? They have had so much time to innovate and make some real progress. They also have a lot of money as market leaders. Yet they have not focussed on reducing costs by innovation or by economies of scale or creating a single compelling electric scooter.
The Big question is ​
Why should you and I - the public - fund such a company that does not bother innovating?

Ather Energy : Where is the affordable scooter?
At the other end of the spectrum, we have Ather. They say that their scooter costs. Rs 1,90,000 and with the FAME 2 subsidy of Rs 29,000, they are selling their Ather 450X at Rs 1,61,000 in Mumbai. Yes, Ather has made an amazing vehicle and has shown electric scooters can be cool. But Ather has been in the industry for 5+ years and yet they are nowhere close to launching a sub Rs one lakh model. Essentially they don’t seem to care about getting their scooters to be accessible and made affordable to people.
Currently only people who have a lot of money can afford the Ather 450X. Essentially the FAME 2 subsidies are funding Ather and helping the rich.
The Big question is ​
Why should you and I - the public - fund a company that does not bother about creating affordable EV's?

Ideas for FAME 3
  • Don’t bother offering subsidies on electric 2 wheelers for companies who have more than 10 CR investment
  • Offer FAME 3 subsidies only to real startups who have got Series A funding upto 10 CR and have a clear go to market strategy. And let the subsidy be time bound. Also have conditions on pulling them out of the subsidy system if they don’t meet deadlines or commitments.
With this system, subsidies will be offered for new startups who have limited resources. It’s a way to boost our young startups and give them a chance against giants like
Hero Electric, Ather who have large amounts of money and yet are not doing enough for the Indian EV ecosystem.

Or Alternatively 
  • Offer subsidies only for companies that offer two wheelers that have options in all categories.
  • Also take into effect if companies are using components that are genuinely made in India. Component suppliers too have to be considered, if they are just importing a particular component or assembling or manufacturing it?
Picture
Picture

What is the industry saying about this?
Dr Chandrakanth Jain, DEXPRESS
We are principally against subsidy on EV specially 2 wheeler because it is no more a new industry. The subsidy should be given to parts manufacturers if at all the subsidy is to be given and not to vehicle manufacturers. That’s the only way a country can have infrastructure for the industry and compete with the world.
The best way to subsidies EV is to reduce GST on advanced batteries, because it will automatically reduce the cost and improve the quality of EV. It will prevent misuse of taxpayers money. It will give equal playground to all the players and quality will be the only criteria to compete.

Dr Nishanth, PURE EV 
Like all companies in the EV industry, PURE EV too are anyway receiving some or other kind of incentives for setting up industries as per the state and central govt policies
The EV industry should become a mainstream industry quickly. I know the ground level challenges from various aspects especially the supply chain and battery tech, but the OEMs should focus on fixing on those problems rather than worrying too much about the subsidy

Finally
Both Sohinder Gill and Tarun Mehta are looking at what is good for their own companies. That is the problem and they need to be held accountable.
So what do you guys think about this?
  • Do you think Mr Sohinder Gill from Hero Electric is right and we need to offer subsidies on low speed scooters?
  • Do you think Mr Tarun Mehta is right, who says support should continue for  performance EVs?
  • Or do we need to think differently - offer it only to startups and get large companies to innovate and force them to survive without the need for subsidies? 
  • Or do we focus on localization only and offer subsidies based on strong localization

We would appreciate your comments below.
7 Comments
Manmohan
22/2/2021 03:03:16 am

Subsidies should be in 3 parts.

1st 1/3rd component - Give to all who have certain localization percentage to encourage customers to go for EVs over ICE vehicles(with a ceiling of retail price to exclude performance or luxury EV segment).

2nd 1/3rd component - Give to those companies who set up a certain number of charging stations every year.

3rd UPTO 1/3rd component - indirect subsidy on purchase of components of certain types identified by the Govt, if their production is shifted to India.

Reply
메이저토토사이트 link
1/7/2022 06:52:18 am

I read your article in an instant. You have no idea how hard I've been trying to find a good article on this topic for a week. I think that's why your writing shines more. Thank you so much for sharing good information. I'll look for more of your posts. And I think my writing on the topic you wrote will help you. I hope you come to my blog and read it.

Reply
먹튀검증 link
1/7/2022 06:52:37 am

I think this article is very useful. It's full of information for my work. Thanks to you, I'm glad I got a lot of good information. Thank you for writing this article. :D

Reply
totoguy link
14/7/2022 07:31:21 am

In the meantime, I wondered why I couldn't think of the answer to this simple problem like this. Your article is an article that gives the answer to all the content I've been contemplating. I'm very lucky to find your blog. Thank you for the good information.

Reply
totovi link
14/7/2022 07:31:35 am

Full of information that I really enjoy reading. I think writing is a way of influencing people to rate things they should be grateful for. I'd say it's very useful and enlightening. I'm sure there are more good topics on my blog that you can write about. Please come and check.

Reply
totoright link
14/7/2022 07:31:48 am

Well, why did I finally find this posting? I wish I had known you sooner. Your posting was useful to me. Thank you for posting a good article. May I quote your posting on my blog? Check it out on my blog.

Reply
online casino link
29/9/2022 08:21:50 am

You there, this is really good post here. Thanks for taking the time to post such valuable information.

Reply

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Ask Your EV Guru
    Blogs From Heart & Soul
    Buyers Guides
    Charging Stations
    Clean Energy
    Commercial Vehicles
    Community Initiatives
    Conversion Kits
    Electric Bikes
    Electric Bus
    Electric Cars
    Electric MotorCycles
    Electric Scooters
    Events
    EV Expos & Exhibitions
    EV Industry News
    EV Sales
    EV Technology
    EV Travelogues
    How To Guides
    Interviews
    Podcasts
    RE:LIVE Events
    Student Projects
    Surveys

    Archives

    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    March 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013

    RSS Feed

Plug in india

About us
Advertise with us
Contact us

Privacy Policy
Terms of Service

Support US

Get access to exclusive perks
  • Become a YouTube member
  • Become a Patreon

Subscribe to our newsletter

© COPYRIGHT 2019. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
  • Home
  • EV News
  • EV Blogs
  • Podcast
  • Videos
  • Vehicles
    • Sales
    • Electric Cars
    • Tata Electric Cars
    • OLA Electric
    • Power Electric Scooters
    • Economy Scooters
    • Electric Cycles
    • Electric MotorCycles
    • Electric Cargo Vehicles
    • Campus Vehicles
  • Categories
    • Community Charging
    • Buyer's Guides
    • Real Life EV Stories
    • How To Guides
    • EV Test Reports
    • EV Travelogues
    • EV Conversions
    • Events
    • Educate
  • About Us
  • Community
    • Discord
    • Forums